Comprehensive School Physical Activity Program Survey Report
Executive Summary
Introduction
The purpose of the 2011 Comprehensive School Physical Activity Program (CSPAP) Survey is to better understand the extent to which schools across the United States are implementing the components of a CSPAP at the elementary, middle, and high school levels. The CSPAP model is an approach by which school districts and schools provide a variety of opportunities for school-based physical activity to develop physically educated students who participate in the nationally-recommended 60 or more minutes of physical activity each day and develop the knowledge, skills, and confidence to be physically active for a lifetime. The CSPAP model consists of five components: physical education, physical activity during school, physical activity before and after school, staff involvement, and family and community involvement.
The 2011 CSPAP Survey is a baseline survey that is intended to be conducted periodically to measure progress and assess trends related to before-, during-, and after-school physical activity. Specifically, the survey can be used as a data source for measuring progress on the National Physical Activity Plan education sector strategy to "provide access to and opportunities for high-quality, comprehensive physical activity programs, anchored by physical education, in pre-kindergarten through grade 12 educational settings."1 Additionally, findings from the survey will be used to inform the Let's Move in School initiative being conducted by the American Alliance for Health, Physical Education, Recreation and Dance (AAHPERD). The goal of Let's Move in School is to ensure that every school provides a CSPAP with quality physical education as the foundation. Furthermore, this survey builds upon and deepens the findings from previously conducted national surveys and reports and provides information about the current status of CSPAP implementation in our nation's schools.
Methods
The survey was conducted electronically, using Survey Monkey, in the spring of 2011 without a systematic sampling technique. It was promoted to AAHPERD members via the AAHPERD website and e-mail announcements and to non-members through AAHPERD's network of state organizations and organizational and corporate partners. The survey included seven sections: demographics, five CSPAP components, and comments on successes and challenges of implementing a CSPAP. Over three-quarters (78%) of the individuals who started the survey completed it (1,225 of 1,566 individuals), and 94% of survey participants were physical educators.
Key Findings
The following key findings were identified from the survey participants' responses to the five CSPAP component sections.
Physical Education
- Physical education is most commonly provided in grades 1-5 (90% of schools). The percentage of schools that provide physical education declines through middle school and reaches a low in grade 12 at 44% of schools.
- In the majority of schools (92%), physical education is taught by a state-certified physical education teacher.
|
Physical Activity During School
- Scheduled recess is provided in the majority of elementary schools (over 80%). The percentage of schools that provide recess declines through middle school and reaches a low in high school at 10-11% of schools.
- Among elementary schools that have scheduled recess, over three-quarters (76%) provide it five days/week, and nearly two-thirds (65%) allot between 15-29 minutes for each recess period.
- Almost one-third of elementary schools (31%) have a policy or practice that prevents recess from being withheld as a behavioral consequence or form of punishment.
- In nearly two-thirds (61%) of elementary schools, physical activity is integrated into classrooms by at least some classroom teachers. Specifically, integration of physical activity occurs between lessons (56% of schools), during lessons (44% of schools), and at the start of the day (43% of schools).
- Approximately one-third of elementary school classroom teachers are given support for integrating physical activity into the classroom through the provision of physical activity equipment (39% of schools), professional development/training (37% of schools), and/or turn-key resources (32% of schools).
|
Physical Activity Before and After School
- A walk/bike to school program is most commonly present in elementary schools (22%) as compared to middle schools (16%) and high schools (11%).
- Almost two-thirds of schools (63%) offer physical activity clubs and/or intramural sports.
- In 55% of schools, at least 25% of the male student population participates in a minimum of one physical activity club or intramural sport, compared to 49% of schools where this same criterion is met by females.
- In the transition from middle school to high school, there is a large drop in schools that have more than one-fourth of their student population participating in at least one physical activity club or intramural sport. Schools with students meeting this criterion drop from 62% in middle school to 50% in high school for males and 53% in middle school to 40% in high school for females.
- Interscholastic sports are most commonly provided by high schools (89%) and least frequently provided by elementary schools (14%). In 70% of high schools at least 25% of males participate in one or more interscholastic sports and this same criterion is met by females in 58% of high schools.
- Almost two-thirds of high schools (65%) have cut policies in interscholastic sports.
- Before- and/or after-school child care is offered in 63% of elementary schools. Time is allotted for physical activity in 38% of before-school programs and 88% of after-school programs.
- One-third (32%) of before- and/or after-school child care program employees have received training on facilitating physical activity.
|
Staff Involvement
- Employee physical activity classes are offered by 42% of schools or districts. But, less than half of staff members participate in these activities in most of these schools (87%).
- Almost two-thirds of schools (63%) conducted or planned to conduct events in which staff members engage in physical activity with students.
- Approximately one-fourth of schools (23%) participated in National Sport and Physical Education Week.
- Most schools (85%) reported that an administrator observed at least 10 minutes of their physical education class at least one time during the school year, and 31% of schools reported observations five or more times within the school year.
- Fifty percent or more of schools reported using the following methods to create a culture or environment to reinforce physical activity: (1) including information about physical education and physical activity in written communication (65%), (2) presence of a school health advisory or wellness committee (56%), (3) having goals related to physical education and physical activity in the school improvement plan (50%), and (4) including physical education and physical activity in school-wide events (50%).
|
Family and Community Involvement
- Over half (55%) of schools conducted or were planning to conduct events in which families were invited to engage in physical activity with students. Over two-thirds of the elementary schools (67%) conducted or planned to conduct these events, while slightly more than one-fourth (27%) of high schools had a similar plan.
- Nearly one-third of schools surveyed students on their thoughts about the school physical education and physical activity programs.
- Related to the availability of school facilities for open use by students or community members before or after school, most often outdoor facilities were available (68%) followed by gymnasiums (39%). School fitness centers were least available at 10% and were also the facility type schools were least likely to have, with 50% of schools reporting that they do not have a fitness center.
- Most frequently, collaborations between schools and community-based organizations to enhance school and physical activity opportunities occurred between schools and youth sports leagues and/or park and recreation agencies.
|
Key Messages
- Efforts related to program and policy enhancement must be undertaken to increase the percentage of schools that provide activities in all five CSPAP components, which is currently only 16% of elementary schools, 13% of middle schools, and 6% of high schools.
- With childhood obesity at an all-time high, it is essential to create environments that support physical activity participation. Schools are the most important setting for promoting and providing physical activity because time spent in school accounts for the majority of weekday waking hours for most children.
- The CSPAP model is an approach for providing a comprehensive program whereby the school is fully utilizing time and resources to conduct activities in all CSPAP components.
- To provide for coordination of the CSPAP, schools could employ a director of physical activity (DPA). A DPA would be the trained expert in the school with the knowledge and capability to integrate and implement all components of a CSPAP.
- AAHPERD's Let's Move in School initiative, which has the goal of ensuring that every school provides a CSPAP with quality physical education as the foundation, is a hub for information, tools, and resources to increase before-, during-, and after-school physical activity in our nation's schools.
1 National Physical Activity Plan. U.S. National Physical Activity Plan. Columbia, SC, 2010.